Sunday, September 9, 2007

Copyright and Fair Use SR

I was surprised by the answer to number two. I guessed correctly that the answer was false, but I did not assume that even though all the students have access to Photoshop on the central server, only one computer at a time can use the software. It seems like that would be hard to enforce.

The extension of number six surprised me. It makes sense that teachers should be able to use pictures and information from the internet for their units, but I did not realize that it would be illegal for them to post it back up online as part of their own projects, even if they site the website they originally got them from.

The answer to number eight was not what I expected. I thought that if you could download something online, other than on limewire or things like that, that it was legal. I didn't know there were other types of file-sharing websites that would cause your material to not be legitimately acquired.

I found number nine interesting. I had heard that mp3.com was a legal site, unlike limewire, but I never understood why. The answer to this question really makes me understand the meaning of "legitimately acquired".

I was not aware that things like number 14 were illegal. Many times in school we would watch movies just to watch movies. There was no educational purpose.

I thought that the answer to number 15 was very surprising. I also found it somewhat ambiguous. Is it illegal to pick out clips from movies and stick each videotape in separately, or is it illegal to make a compilation on the computer?

I didn't even know they made the kind of machine discussed in number 16, but it was obvious that that type of machine would be made illegal. However, it makes sense that teachers would be able to use them if they could get their hands on one, as long as they didn't use it for anything but educational uses.

I found the answer to number 19 particularly interesting. Even though the music was being used as part of an educational activity, it was not found to be an educational use of the songs, and therefore illegal. Also, I don't understand why it makes a difference if they use the whole song or a clip of the song.

1 comment:

TexasTheresa said...

you obviously learned a lot from this activity. good reflection.
:>dr.theresa